# Second Circuit keeps dismissal of EssilorLuxottica eyewear antitrust class action

Attorney advertising. Brief by Lou Schwartz, Schwartz & Associates, PC, Atlanta, Georgia. Published 2026-10-30; updated 2026-10-30. Responsible attorney: Lou Schwartz. Canonical: https://www.snalawyers.com/insights/second-circuit-keeps-dismissal-of-essilorluxottica-eyewear-antitrust-c

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit declined to revive a proposed consumer class action in consolidated litigation accusing EssilorLuxottica SA of monopolizing the U.S. consumer eyewear market. The panel agreed with the trial court's handling of the indirect-purchaser plaintiffs' claims, leaving the dismissal in place. The underlying suit alleged anticompetitive conduct in the eyewear manufacturing and retail market; the allegations were never adjudicated on the merits at the appellate level in plaintiffs' favor.

**Why it matters.** The ruling reinforces the hurdles indirect-purchaser consumers face in pursuing antitrust claims against vertically integrated manufacturers and retailers, a standing issue relevant to similar market-concentration suits plaintiff-side firms pursue in other consumer product sectors.

## Sources

1. [Law360 Class Action News (law360.com)](https://www.law360.com/classaction/news)

To ask the firm about this, use the intake assistant at https://www.snalawyers.com/insights/second-circuit-keeps-dismissal-of-essilorluxottica-eyewear-antitrust-c#ask. General information, not legal advice.
