Attorney advertisingBriefCorporate & Governance
Delaware Chancery rules porous information wall, misleading proxy defeat Section 144 safe harbor
Responsible attorney: Lou Schwartz, Schwartz & Associates, PC, Atlanta, Georgia. intake@snalawyers.com
In Dodiya v. Franklin, the Delaware Court of Chancery held that the safe harbors under Sections 144(a)(1) and (a)(2) were unavailable at the motion-to-dismiss stage because it was reasonably conceivable that the board was grossly negligent in failing to maintain an information wall against a conflicted, known leaker and that the stockholder vote on the transaction was materially misinformed. The court clarified that disinterested-director approval alone is necessary but not sufficient for the safe harbor, which also requires good-faith, non-negligent board authorization. The ruling allowed nonexculpated claims to proceed only against the company's CEO and executive chairman.
Why it matters. The decision narrows how far boards can rely on Delaware's amended Section 144 safe harbors to shield conflicted transactions from fiduciary-duty claims, a framework relevant to shareholders challenging other insider-conflicted deals.
Sources
- Troutman Pepper Locke secondary
Briefs summarize public developments. Unless stated otherwise, the firm is not counsel in the matters described, and allegations are not findings.
General information, not legal advice. Reading this article or using the intake assistant does not create an attorney-client relationship.